chrismukkah- what the heck?!?!?!?
okay, here goes the first blogblond rant:
i just read about this great new idea for interfaith families: chrismukkah (no, i am not making this up!). there is a new line of cards, gifts, and paraphanelia for families who didn't respect their own religion or traditions enough to want to perpetuate them by marrying someone of their own faith. don't get me wrong here- marry who you want, but if your list of what you really want in a spouse does not include sharing your core values about religion, then don't incorporate pseudo-values after the fact so you can give and receive gifts. that's part one.
part two is that chanukah is not a major holiday, and there is no reason to give gifts- other than to pacify jewish kids in public schools whose christian friends are winning the gift lottery every december, while in their own jewish homes, they are getting fried potato pancakes. christmas, from what i understand, is also not supposed to be about gifts. the whole tree idea was just to pacify little christian kids in public school whose pagan friends had cool fertitlity rituals, while in their own christian homes they had long religious services celebrating the birth of their lord.
so, we have two religious holidays that have become bastardized, secularized, and rendered basically meaningless when celebrated by non-religious (well, not in 'that way') practicioners. and into this mix comes chismukkah, to further remove any sense of true meaning from the celebrations. so, i am the grinchblond? no- i am all for giving and receiving gifts- just be honest and call it what it is: i worship myself day. or it's all about me day. i want to get more stuff, to stuff in the few places in my home that are not already stuffed with stuff- so please ante up the loot. think of the t-shirt sales on those two suggestions alone!
i guess what i'm saying is- just don't make up holidays. holidays are supposed to be HOLY days- thus the word 'holiday'- so if you want to have a day, that's great. if you want to make up new reasons to celebrate, go ahead (look at hallmark). if you want to give gifts, or send fruitcakes, or light up your house like a runway, or have an office party so you can hook up with your coworker and then claim afterward that you were really really drunk, well, knock yourself out. but don't alienate people from their religious origins even more by dressing something in the guise of religion and passing it off to those too far removed from their own authentic traditions to recognize it.
and if you are a christian who doesn't embrace your own tradition and wear it with pride, and wish people merry christmas during the season because you are afraid to offend them- watch out, cuz i'm gonna come after you next...
i just read about this great new idea for interfaith families: chrismukkah (no, i am not making this up!). there is a new line of cards, gifts, and paraphanelia for families who didn't respect their own religion or traditions enough to want to perpetuate them by marrying someone of their own faith. don't get me wrong here- marry who you want, but if your list of what you really want in a spouse does not include sharing your core values about religion, then don't incorporate pseudo-values after the fact so you can give and receive gifts. that's part one.
part two is that chanukah is not a major holiday, and there is no reason to give gifts- other than to pacify jewish kids in public schools whose christian friends are winning the gift lottery every december, while in their own jewish homes, they are getting fried potato pancakes. christmas, from what i understand, is also not supposed to be about gifts. the whole tree idea was just to pacify little christian kids in public school whose pagan friends had cool fertitlity rituals, while in their own christian homes they had long religious services celebrating the birth of their lord.
so, we have two religious holidays that have become bastardized, secularized, and rendered basically meaningless when celebrated by non-religious (well, not in 'that way') practicioners. and into this mix comes chismukkah, to further remove any sense of true meaning from the celebrations. so, i am the grinchblond? no- i am all for giving and receiving gifts- just be honest and call it what it is: i worship myself day. or it's all about me day. i want to get more stuff, to stuff in the few places in my home that are not already stuffed with stuff- so please ante up the loot. think of the t-shirt sales on those two suggestions alone!
i guess what i'm saying is- just don't make up holidays. holidays are supposed to be HOLY days- thus the word 'holiday'- so if you want to have a day, that's great. if you want to make up new reasons to celebrate, go ahead (look at hallmark). if you want to give gifts, or send fruitcakes, or light up your house like a runway, or have an office party so you can hook up with your coworker and then claim afterward that you were really really drunk, well, knock yourself out. but don't alienate people from their religious origins even more by dressing something in the guise of religion and passing it off to those too far removed from their own authentic traditions to recognize it.
and if you are a christian who doesn't embrace your own tradition and wear it with pride, and wish people merry christmas during the season because you are afraid to offend them- watch out, cuz i'm gonna come after you next...
13 Comments:
At Tuesday, December 06, 2005 11:05:00 AM, Anonymous said…
I think you make some very good points - I think all holidays have become way to comercialized. It seems like people are afraid to be religios but have some kind of yearning for something meaningful. As it is "not cool" to be a religous freak - Chismuka becomes a holiday where they can pacify their yearning for something non threatening - what they don't realize is that it really doesn't fulfil your need doing something empty and meaningless - it only puts a band aid on a growing wound.
At Tuesday, December 06, 2005 11:07:00 AM, Anonymous said…
The blonde makes some very good points. Christmas is too commercial. It has lost the spirit of the true meaning by many. But I bet you can say the same about Chanukah, those who celebrate with out realizing the true meaning. (IE people who celebrate both) I am trying to push into my daughter the true meaning of Christmas, it is not about Santa Claus and toys. It is very difficult. You know we never celebrated Christmas in America until the late 19th century. Hell, Washington's most famous battle was fought on Christmas day.
At Tuesday, December 06, 2005 12:36:00 PM, Sarah said…
Here's another conundrum (sp?) - why is there a Christmas tree in the foyer of my school this year? I wonder if they'd care if I got one of those big Lubavitch-style electric menorahs to put at the other end of the foyer... Of course, then we'd have to add a manger scene or some such to represent pagan fertility, xmas, and Chanukah...
At Tuesday, December 06, 2005 1:25:00 PM, BlogBlond said…
i wonder why there is no popular movement among religious people who are not fanatics/freaks to put meaning back into all of our holidays??
At Tuesday, December 06, 2005 1:42:00 PM, Anonymous said…
Shame on all of you for not even a mention of Kwanza. Disgusting.
Anyway, the truth is this blog is truly a Chrinikkah miracle to be shared by all.
Welcoome to blogland BlogBlond. Any friend is anysara is an any friend of mine.
At Tuesday, December 06, 2005 4:52:00 PM, Lawyer-Wearing-Yarmulka said…
Chrismukkah is just the natural evolution of using "Holidays" instead of Christmas".
People say happy holidays instead of merry christmas because they don't want to, god forbid, offend anyone, cuz they might be Jewish and celebrate Channuka
So if Holiday is just a euphimism for for Channuka and Christmas, why not just merge the two into one large, narcissistic yom tov!
At Tuesday, December 06, 2005 4:57:00 PM, BlogBlond said…
yeah- so that's a perfect lead-in for my next post. stay tuned...
At Wednesday, December 07, 2005 7:27:00 PM, Josh said…
Two points - The religious right has reacted out of frustration to the de-religifying of holidays. Also, the OC had a full episode dedicated to this issue. What blonde could pass up that reference?
At Thursday, December 08, 2005 6:09:00 AM, BlogBlond said…
josh- first of all, thanks for that link! verrrrrrrrry interesting reading!
this quote from that article is comment-worthy:
"Then along comes a generic season's greeting from the White House, paid for by the Republican National Committee. The cover art is also secular, if not humanist: It shows the presidential pets -- two dogs and a cat -- frolicking on a snowy White House lawn."
so, what i want to know is, what is humanist about two dogs and a cat? maybe that is pettist, or beastist, but why humanist? perhaps it is the frolicking part that is humanist- after all, what self-respecting humanist doesn't like a good frolick now and then? or maybe it is the snow? since humans made snow, through their use of deoderents- oh, no, that's greenhouse gasses, sorry...is it the idea of having a lawn? because CLEARLY that is not a religious idea.... yeah, rough night last nioght- sorry...
At Thursday, December 08, 2005 6:10:00 AM, BlogBlond said…
oh yeah, and what is OC?? (yes, you have been outblonded!) but seriously...
At Friday, December 09, 2005 4:17:00 AM, Josh said…
Um, "Orange County" on FOX...
At Friday, December 09, 2005 5:24:00 AM, BlogBlond said…
never heard of it, sorry. do they have it on dvd?
At Sunday, December 11, 2005 9:26:00 AM, Anonymous said…
nothing really to do with the blog, but has anyone actually seen one of those upside down christmas trees??? they are supposed to be all the rage and apperently, the greatest thing, think about it, more gift space?? what is up with this world?? we are all upside down. for those of you have already heard me mention this random thought on many a shabbos afternoon i appologize.
Post a Comment
<< Home